City Planning Commission considers White House zoning change proposal

Marlene Cody, a vice president for the Greater Whitestone Taxpayers Civic Association, speaks against the proposed rezoning of the Whitestone block that is home to the White House restaurant at a city Planning Commission hearing. Photo by Connor Adams Sheets
By Connor Adams Sheets

The city Planning Commission Wednesday considered a proposal by a Whitestone restaurant owner to rezone the block containing his property so he can upgrade and expand the eatery.

Supporters of the proposal by Joe Franco, the White House restaurant’s owner, and about a dozen community members opposed to the plan voiced their opinions on the project, which has become a major point of controversy in the waterside neighborhood.

The zoning change would allow certain types of two-story residential and commercial buildings to be built on the entire east end of the block of 154th Street from 10th Avenue to 11th Avenue.

Whitestone resident Geri Entler, an employee of Franco’s, said the block is already largely commercial and that expanding the restaurant at 10-24 154th St. — currently a one-story building with a partial second floor —  to have catering facilities on a larger footprint with a new, expansive, second-floor party space would bring benefits to the area.

“It will create many part-time jobs and full-time jobs, more than 100,” she told the commission. “We just need a revitalization and an uplift in the neighborhood. It’s full of drug addicts and needs a change.”

But opponents say Franco’s plan is too far-reaching. Under his proposal, the property would not be the only one affected; the whole block would be upzoned to accommodate certain types of larger, two-story residential buildings and to allow commercial activity.

Borough President Helen Marshall approved the project before it advanced to the Planning Commission, and she recommended that only the residential upzoning move forward on the rest of the block, leaving the restaurant as the only new commercial property.

But residents of the block including Brian Garry, who lives in the adjacent home to the north, and other concerned community members say the application should be withdrawn and Franco should apply for a narrow variance instead, so the rest of the block will retain its current zoning.

Marlene Cody, a vice president with the Greater Whitestone Taxpayers Civic Association, presented a petition with the signatures of 162 project opponents to the commission.

“We need to be responsible here. A variance could build a very nice catering hall and all would be in agreement,” she said. “This would be a very large-scale facility with serious impacts on the community.”

The White House was sold to Franco by longtime principal owner Matty Geoghegan last month. In 2009 Franco, the former proprietor of Caffé on the Green in Bayside, lost the license for the city Parks Department concession, which now is operated as Valentino’s on the Green.

A lawyer for Franco has said the project is expected to break ground this fall or in early 2012, and that construction could be completed as early as fall 2012.

Reach reporter Connor Adams Sheets by e-mail at csheets@cnglocal.com or by phone at 718-260-4538.

More from Around New York